It seems you're using an old browser. In order to view this site correctly, we advise you to upgrade your browser, or try the free Mozilla Firefox.

Print Email


Voices si, acting no

Rossini's Barber doesn't quite cut it at MOT.

Pictured (l to r): Earle Patriarco, Vivica Genaux & Bruce Fowler.
More Opera Stories

Opera made to look easy (3/31/2010)
The rise, fall and proud return of a Detroit diva

Vintage vixen (6/7/2006)
A Salome to lose your head over

ĎA fun, demented girlí (6/7/2006)

More from George Bulanda

Oceanic reveries (6/7/2000)
MOT's Peter Grimes swells with pure musical drama.

Kiss me deadly (5/24/2000)
MOT excels with Puccini's grandly tragic Tosca.

S/he loves me (not) (4/19/2000)
Strauss' wistfully comic opera ponders mortality and bends gender.


Published 10/6/1999

Though itís well sung, in the main, and the pace travels at a merry gait, Michigan Opera Theatreís production of Rossiniís The Barber of Seville has virtually no dramatic propulsion. You just donít get the sense that the characters are motivated. They plot and scheme, but they seem merely to be going through their paces. Under Dorothy Dannerís largely spiritless direction, the cast lacks the emotional and dramatic drive to make their charactersí actions believable.

Barber is a comedy, but thereís a black undertow that serves as its dramatic springboard. Scheming, lying and duplicity are integral to the charactersí makeup, and the wiliest ones triumph. This is a cream puff comedy with a somewhat sour filling.

Count Almaviva disguises himself and fibs to woo Rosina, whose sly machinations make her more than just the ditsy coquette sheís often portrayed as. Rosinaís guardian, Doctor Bartolo, ends up being duped, but not after scheming to win Rosinaís hand and drive Almaviva away.

Another rogue, Basilio, conspires to help Bartolo. Figaro is intent on uniting Almaviva and Rosina, not because he wants to aid the young lovers, but because heís getting paid handsomely for it. No one is morally spotless in this opera, but no one is really nefarious, either. Itís good, dirty fun, driven by relentless manipulation.

To Dannerís credit, she doesnít make Barber a spectacle of slapstick humor, which mars so many productions of this opera. However, having Bartoloís servants constantly sneeze and yawn is not only unfunny, but downright irritating.

As Count Almaviva, Bruce Fowler spins off Rossiniís garlands of coloratura with aplomb. Fowler is a true leggiero tenor who can negotiate the bel canto music without strain. However, he does little dramatically to alter the perception that Almaviva is just a rich, moonstruck wimp.

Earle Patriarco makes a robust entrance as Figaro, singing "Largo al factotum" with earthy elan. But after his opening aria, he gradually drains his character of color. Heís too docile to play a rapscallion.

Vivica Genaux dashes off Rosinaís difficult scales and roulades with ease. Her timbre and flexibility recall one of the great Rosinas, the Spanish mezzo Teresa Berganza. But Genaux imparts none of the sly humor Berganza brought to the role. Genauxís vocal filigree is impressive in her duet with Figaro, but her acting is rather square. Still, youíve got to give Genaux credit for keeping her composure in last Saturdayís opening night performance when the house lights inexplicably and annoyingly came on shortly after her entrance aria, "Una voce poco fa."

Donato Di Stefano looks convincing as the rotund old buffoon Bartolo, and itís refreshing to see a Bartolo who doesnít milk the part for every ounce of wacky humor he can. Di Stefano, though, sounds more like a bass-baritone than a basso buffo. Bass Michele Bianchini brings little definition or vim to the role of Basilio.

Conductor Stewart Robertsonís sprightly tempos are invigorating. However, itís disappointing to hear Robertsonís inattention to Rossiniís trademark crescendos, which should begin softly, gather steam gradually and explode like Vesuvius. The overtureís crescendos, for instance, were played at virtually the same audibility, with almost no variation in dynamics.

On Oct. 8 and 10, Zheng Cao alternates as Rosina; Marian Pop plays Figaro and Lorenzo Marroccu is Almaviva.

E-mail comments to

blog comments powered by Disqus